Five Emails, One Tuesday Morning… Zero Impact
One of your high-potential employees opened their email at 5:58 this morning. These were the five messages at the top of their inbox.
How many do you think they’ll…
- Delete without opening?
- Open, and forget immediately?
- Act on?
- 5:55 a.m., from IT: “Your mailbox is almost full. Archive or delete messages to keep getting messages.” Ironically, the only one in the stack that understands the problem. And hey, a clear CTA, at least.
- 11:20 p.m. last night, from Workday: “You have 1 pending task.” Clicking through, they see something they already did but the confirmation didn’t stick. 2FA is required to go in and fix it, but the auth prompt times out.
- 5:50 p.m. yesterday afternoon, from “everybody” via Corp Comms: “The [corporate newsletter], November edition” 14 article slugs and “Click to read more!” buttons. Fine (I guess) so far… but “Welcoming Our New Model” is the only item that explains a recent re-org, and it’s #7 on the list.
- 3:30 p.m. yesterday afternoon, from Benefits: “Want an FSA Next Year? Reminder to Re-Enroll by Nov. 30.” Now we’re getting somewhere! Important, actionable, timely. But instructions and a link to the enrollment system are buried in paragraph 3, after “We hope this finds you well” and a plug for the new wellness program. And…a 3:30 p.m. send?
- 12:00 noon sharp yesterday, from Facilities: “Refrigerator Cleanout Friday at 2:00 p.m.” Triggers a flood of “Remove me” replies—and some accidental(?) reply-alls from fully remote or international employees who couldn’t care less.
___
The tally:
- One (arguably, two) are “urgent.”
- Two needed a re-think. They’re either not relevant to the recipient, or the result of a system glitch nobody’s fixed yet.
- And, at least one buries the really important story.
All of these are, no doubt, important to the person or team who sent them. It’s hard to point fingers with limited context.
But here’s what you can realistically expect.
- Up to 40% will get trashed immediately (before the Preview Pane can even render them).
- Up to 40% might get skimmed…but you can’t be sure the important message landed.
- And 20% have no business being broadcast emails at all. (Hang signs on the fridges and get on with your day. Don’t hassle Corp Comms.)
___
Questions to ask before sending next time (and if you need help putting guardrails around these in your own organization, ping me):
- Consequences: “What happens if the employee ignores this?” If it’s nothing, put it in a digest or don’t send it at all. If it’s bad, make it single-issue and top-priority with a subject line that says so.
- Governance: “Who owns the send?” Being democratic (giving every team/function their own “Send” button) creates this problem. Think “shared comms calendar, a volume cap per audience per [day/week/month], and an editor-in-chief to enforce them.”
- Outcomes, not sends: “How will we know this email was effective?” Open rates tell you little about behavior (hello, Preview Pane), and absolutely nothing about impact on objectives (e.g., FSA enrollments by the deadline). Count what matters, and adjust the comms levers based on those.
___
Photo by Markus Kammermann for Unsplash.